Buffalo Bill's Pumpkin Ale - Tasting Panel Review of Buffalo Bill's Pumpkin Ale

According to my beer tasting panel Buffalo Bill's Pumpkin Ale was a better beer than O'fallon Pumpkin Beer.

Pros

Cons

This ale was reported to have an amber color. The aroma was generally described as subtle with pineapple notes. The flavor brought a wide variety of reactions. Notes of smooth fruitiness, peaches, spices and oranges were recorded. One taster said that she detected the flavor of pickled peaches with hints of cinnamon. Overall, the panel enjoyed this beer although the self described beer snobs in the crowd did not enjoy it's unusual flavors.